A cohort study, systematic review, and meta-analysis28 min read
We aimed to investigate the association of serum pentadecanoic acid (15:0), a biomarker of dairy fat intake, with incident cardiovascular disease (CVD) and all-cause mortality in a Swedish cohort study. We also systematically reviewed studies of the association of dairy fat biomarkers (circulating or adipose tissue levels of 15:0, heptadecanoic acid [17:0], and trans-palmitoleic acid [t16:1n-7]) with CVD outcomes or all-cause mortality.
Methods and findings
We measured 15:0 in serum cholesterol esters at baseline in 4,150 Swedish adults (51% female, median age 60.5 years). During a median follow-up of 16.6 years, 578 incident CVD events and 676 deaths were identified using Swedish registers. In multivariable-adjusted models, higher 15:0 was associated with lower incident CVD risk in a linear dose–response manner (hazard ratio 0.75 per interquintile range; 95% confidence interval 0.61, 0.93, P = 0.009) and nonlinearly with all-cause mortality (P for nonlinearity = 0.03), with a nadir of mortality risk around median 15:0. In meta-analyses including our Swedish cohort and 17 cohort, case–cohort, or nested case–control studies, higher 15:0 and 17:0 but not t16:1n-7 were inversely associated with total CVD, with the relative risk of highest versus lowest tertile being 0.88 (0.78, 0.99), 0.86 (0.79, 0.93), and 1.01 (0.91, 1.12), respectively. Dairy fat biomarkers were not associated with all-cause mortality in meta-analyses, although there were ≤3 studies for each biomarker. Study limitations include the inability of the biomarkers to distinguish different types of dairy foods and that most studies in the meta-analyses (including our novel cohort study) only assessed biomarkers at baseline, which may increase the risk of misclassification of exposure levels.
In a meta-analysis of 18 observational studies including our new cohort study, higher levels of 15:0 and 17:0 were associated with lower CVD risk. Our findings support the need for clinical and experimental studies to elucidate the causality of these relationships and relevant biological mechanisms.
Why was this study done?
- Many dietary guidelines recommend limiting dairy fat consumption in order to lower saturated fat intake and cardiovascular disease (CVD) risk.
- However, increasing evidence suggests that the health impact of dairy foods is more dependent on the type (e.g., cheese, yoghurt, milk, and butter) rather than the fat content, which has raised doubts if avoidance of dairy fats is beneficial for cardiovascular health.
- Dairy foods are a major source of nutrients, and their consumption is increasing worldwide; thus, it is important to advance our understanding of the impact of dairy fat on CVD risk.
What did the researchers do and find?
- We measured dairy fat consumption using an objective biomarker, serum pentadecanoic acid (15:0), in 4,150 Swedish 60-year-olds and collected information about CVD events and deaths during a median follow-up of 16.6 years.
- When we accounted for known risk factors including demographics, lifestyle, and disease prevalence, the CVD risk was lowest for those with high levels of the dairy fat biomarker 15:0, while those with biomarker levels around the median had the lowest risk of all-cause mortality.
- We also conducted a systematic review and meta-analysis, and the combined evidence from 18 studies also showed higher levels of 2 dairy fat biomarkers (15:0 and heptadecanoic acid 17:0) were linked with lower risk of CVD, but not with all-cause mortality.
What do these findings mean?
- The findings from our study using fatty acid biomarkers suggest that higher intake of dairy fat were associated with lower CVD risk in diverse populations including Sweden (a country with high dairy intake), though more trials are needed to understand if and how dairy foods protect cardiovascular health.
Citation: Trieu K, Bhat S, Dai Z, Leander K, Gigante B, Qian F, et al. (2021) Biomarkers of dairy fat intake, incident cardiovascular disease, and all-cause mortality: A cohort study, systematic review, and meta-analysis. PLoS Med 18(9):
Academic Editor: Sanjay Basu, Harvard Medical School, UNITED STATES
Received: February 17, 2021; Accepted: August 11, 2021; Published: September 21, 2021
Copyright: © 2021 Trieu et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Data Availability: Data from the systematic review are within the manuscript and Supporting information files. Due to legal restrictions, some access restrictions apply to the remaining data underlying the findings. Requests could be sent to Karolinska Institutet, Contact details: Karolinska Institutet, 171 77 Stockholm, Sweden, Telephone: +46 8 524 800, https://ki.se/en/about/how-can-we-help-you.
Funding: This work was supported by funds to UdF from Stockholm County Council (Stockholms Läns Landsting), Swedish Heart and Lung-Foundation (Hjärt-Lungfonden), the Swedish Research Council (Vetenskapsrådet). UR was supported by Swedish Heart and Lung-Foundation (Hjärt-Lungfonden). KT, JW and MM are researchers within a National Health and Medical Research Council of Australia (NHMRC) Centre for Research Excellence in reducing salt intake using food policy interventions (APP1117300). KT was supported by an Early Career Fellowship (APP1161597) from the NHMRC and a Postdoctoral Fellowship (Award ID 102140) from the National Heart Foundation of Australia. ZD was supported by a NHMRC project grant (APP1139997). JW was supported by a University of New South Wales Scientia Fellowship. AVAK was supported by National Institutes of Health (T32 CA009001). The funder had no role in the study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
Competing interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
coronary heart disease; CI,
confidence interval; CVD,
cardiovascular disease; HR,
hazard ratio; IQR,
interquintile range; LDL,
low-density lipoprotein; NOS,
Newcastle–Ottawa Scale; PD,
percentile difference; PUFA,
polyunsaturated fatty acid; RR,
Cardiovascular disease (CVD) is the leading cause of mortality worldwide, responsible for almost 1 in every 3 deaths . While in past decades guidelines generally suggested the avoidance of dietary fats for cardiovascular health, there is now growing evidence that the type and dietary source of fat may be more important for CVD risk than the total amount [2,3]. In particular, there is emerging evidence regarding the role of dairy fats and CVD. While increased intake of saturated fat from dairy is expected to increase low-density lipoprotein (LDL) cholesterol, recent human clinical studies found that such effects differ depending on the type of dairy products as well as the processing methods [4,5]. Long-term observational studies have found no association between total dairy consumption and risk of CVD, with differences in association observed for the type of dairy product rather than the amount of fat in dairy products (e.g., regular versus reduced fat dairy products) [4,6,7]. For example, fermented dairy products, such as cheese and yoghurt, may be more protective than milk and butter [8,9]. Such findings have generated debate as to whether dietary or clinical guidelines based predominantly on considerations of the saturated fat content of dairy foods are appropriate .
Studies have traditionally relied upon self-reported measures of dairy fat intake that are subject to recall bias and may be limited in capturing the plethora of dairy-containing foods or by systematic errors in food composition databases . To overcome these limitations, fatty acid composition in tissues or the circulation are increasingly being utilised as biomarkers of dietary fat . Two odd-chain saturated fatty acids, pentadecanoic acid (15:0) and heptadecanoic acid (17:0), and one trans-fatty acid, trans-palmitoleic acid (t16:1n-7), are increasingly used as biomarkers of dairy fat intake because they are mainly found in ruminant foods such as milk and are not strongly influenced by genetic variation [12,13]. Thus, their levels correlate with dairy fat consumption assessed through weighed diet records and 24-hour dietary recalls and change in accordance with dairy food intake in randomised controlled trials [12,14,15].
Since dairy foods are a major source of nutrients and increasingly consumed globally , it is crucial to have a better understanding of the impact of dairy fat intake on CVD risk. Within this context, we aimed to investigate the association of serum pentadecanoic acid (15:0) with incident CVD and all-cause mortality in a Swedish population-based cohort and incorporated these data in a systematic review of prospective studies evaluating the associations of circulating or adipose tissue dairy fat biomarkers (15:0, 17:0, and t16:1n-7) with incident CVD or all-cause mortality.
Study design and population.
The Stockholm Cohort of 60-year-olds (60YO) has been previously described . One-third of men and women aged 60 between 1 July 1997 and 30 June 1998 residing in Stockholm County (n = 5,460) were randomly selected from the population register and invited to participate in the study. Of these, 4,232 (78%) agreed to participate (52% women) and provided informed consent. The participants underwent a health screening, including blood sampling and completion of an extensive questionnaire (S1 Text). For the current analysis, 4,150 participants that had fasting blood samples collected at baseline between 1997 and 1999, and follow-up information until 31 December 2014 were included. The study was approved by the Ethics Committee at Karolinska Institutet, and all participants provided their informed consent to participate.
Blood samples were collected from participants after an overnight fast, and the serum samples were stored at −80 °C. Fatty acid composition in serum cholesterol esters was measured by gas chromatography as described previously . Briefly, serum cholesteryl esters were methylated, extracted in petroleum ether, evaporated under nitrogen, and then redissolved in hexane before analysis by gas chromatography using a 30-m glass capillary column coated with Thermo TR-FRAME; an Agilent Technologies system consisting of model GLAC 6890N, an autosampler 7683, and Agilent ChemStation; with a programmed temperature of between 150 °C to 260 °C. Thirteen different fatty acids were quantified, and the proportion of each was expressed as a percentage of all fatty acids measured. The intra-assay and inter-assay coefficient of variations for 15:0 acid were 3.6% and 7.6%, respectively. As previously described, serum 15:0 was associated with self-reported dairy intake in 60YO (Fig A in S1 File) .
The primary outcomes were incident CVD and all-cause mortality retrieved from the Swedish Hospital Discharge and Cause of Death Registers. Incident CVD was defined as first-time CVD events including fatal and nonfatal myocardial infarction, fatal and nonfatal ischaemic stroke, and hospitalisation resulting from angina pectoris (International Classification of Disease, 10th Revision codes: I20, I21, I25, I46, and I63 to I66) . Secondary outcomes included CVD mortality, defined as deaths caused by CVD, incident coronary heart disease (CHD), and incident ischaemic stroke. CHD and ischaemic stroke were mutually exclusive events such that participants were censored after their first CVD event.
Analytic methods were prespecified in a protocol (S1 Protocol). Participants with CVD at baseline were excluded from the analyses of incident CVD, CHD, and ischaemic stroke. Cox proportional hazard models were used to estimate hazard ratios (HRs) and 95% confidence intervals (CIs) for the association between serum 15:0 with primary and secondary outcomes. Differences in time to first CVD event or death by serum 15:0 levels were estimated using Laplace regression . During follow-up, around 15% of participants died, and a similar number of persons experienced a CVD event. Hence, we estimated the 15th percentile difference (PD) defined as the difference in time (months) by which 15% of exposed versus unexposed had died or experienced an incident CVD event. Evaluation of PD at percentiles lower than the 15th (i.e., first to 14th) provided similar results. Three models were evaluated: (1) crude, without adjustments; (2) age- and sex-adjusted; and (3) multivariable-adjusted including age, sex, BMI, smoking, physical activity, education, alcohol intake, diabetes, drug-treated hypertension, and drug-treated hypercholesterolaemia as covariates (S1 Text). For analyses of all-cause or CVD mortality, the multivariable-adjusted model also included prevalent CVD as a covariate. Multiple imputations (n = 20) were conducted to account for missing covariates. Less than 3% of the study population had missing values for ≥1 covariate, and the frequency of missing values in each covariate was <1%. Serum 15:0 was assessed as a continuous variable (per interquintile range (IQR), defined as the range between the 90th and 10th percentiles) or a categorical variable (quartiles). There was no violation of the proportional hazard assumption based on visual examination of Schoenfield residuals. Restricted cubic splines were used to evaluate potential nonlinear associations. We explored the associations between serum 15:0 and outcomes in subgroup analyses stratified by sex, BMI, and serum n-3 polyunsaturated fatty acid (PUFA) subgroups (< median versus ≥ median).
We conducted sensitivity analyses by (1) adjusting for self-reported dietary habits (vegetable, fruit and berries, lean fish, oily fish, and processed meat intake) (which was not prespecified); (2) excluding participants with prevalent CVD also from analyses of all-cause mortality (in line with analyses of CVD outcomes); (3) restricting analyses to the first 10 years of follow-up to minimise misclassifications attributable to exposure changes over time; and (4) excluding cases in the first 2 years of follow-up to avoid reverse causation because of undetected disease or presence of risk factors at baseline.
This study is reported as per the Strengthening the Reporting of Observational Studies in Epidemiology (STROBE) guideline (S1 Checklist).
Systematic review and meta-analysis
A systematic literature search up to 27 June 2021 was conducted in Medline, Embase, Scopus, Web of Science, and CENTRAL databases using a search strategy detailed in S2 Text . The systematic review followed the PRISMA guidelines (S2 Checklist) and was registered on PROSPERO [CRD42020162551].
Study selection and data extraction.
The studies eligible for inclusion were prospective observational human studies that examined the association between circulating or adipose tissue levels of 15:0, 17:0, or t16:1n-7 at baseline and risk of CVD events or mortality during follow-up. Prospective cohort, case–cohort, and nested case–control studies were included. Studies were excluded if they had a retrospective or cross-sectional design, standard errors were missing or could not be calculated, all participants had CVD at baseline, or they did not adjust for confounders. Two reviewers (SB and ZD) independently screened the studies for eligibility, extracted data, and assessed the quality of studies using the Newcastle–Ottawa Scale (NOS) . Disagreements were resolved by consensus or by involvement of a third reviewer (JW).
Pooled associations of 15:0, 17:0, and t16:1n-7 with CVD outcomes and all-cause mortality were estimated using random effects meta-analysis. The primary outcomes included total CVD and all-cause mortality. CVD, CHD, stroke (incidence and mortality), as well as incident heart failure were evaluated in secondary analyses. For the analysis of total CVD, the effect size estimate for each study was selected in the following order: CVD incidence > CVD mortality > CHD, stroke, or heart failure incidence > CHD or stroke mortality > other CVD outcome. Risk estimates (HR, odds ratio, or relative risk (RR)) for each study were transformed to allow consistent comparisons between the top and bottom tertile of fatty acid distributions (S2 Text). We included multiple risk estimates from the same cohort if they were derived from separate nested case–control studies. In addition to the quantile analysis, dairy fat biomarkers were evaluated as continuous variables (per 1 SD increase) in a subset of studies with relevant information available or retrieved from study authors. For studies that provided estimates of dairy fat biomarkers in more than one biological tissue, one effect estimate was selected using the following hierarchy to preference lipid compartments that reflect longer-term fatty acid intake: adipose tissue > erythrocyte or plasma phospholipids > cholesterol esters > total plasma. The I2 and Q statistics were used to assess heterogeneity of included studies. Publication bias was assessed by visual inspection of funnel plots and statistically using Egger’s and Begg’s tests. Stratified meta-analyses were performed on subgroups defined by age, sex, follow-up duration, and geographic region. We repeated the meta-analysis using a fixed effects models in a sensitivity analysis. All statistical tests were performed with STATA 15 (Stata Corp, College Station, TX), two-sided, and a P < 0.05 was considered statistically significant.
60YO cohort study—Serum 15:0 and incident CVD and mortality
At baseline, median age was 60.5 years, 51% (n = 2,133) were women, median BMI was 26 kg/m2, 8% had prevalent type 2 diabetes, and 9% had prevalent CVD (Table 1 and Table A in S1 File). During a median follow-up duration of 16.6 years, 578 incident CVD events (386 CHD events and 192 ischaemic strokes) occurred over 55,832 person-years and 676 deaths (198 due to CVD) occurred over 64,605 person-years.
In multivariable-adjusted models, higher serum 15:0 was associated with lower incident CVD in a linear dose–response manner (HR 0.75 per IQR; 95% CI 0.61, 0.93, P = 0.009) (Table 2, Fig 1, and Table B in S1 File showing HR per SD and % of total fatty acids). The time by which 15% experienced an incident CVD event increased by 27 months (95% CI: 6, 48) per IQR (Table 2). Evaluating quartiles of serum 15:0, CVD risk was lower at higher 15:0 levels (P-trend = 0.016), with HR of the top versus bottom quartile of 0.76 (95% CI: 0.59, 0.97) after adjustment for confounders (Table 3). In secondary analyses, higher serum 15:0 was significantly associated with lower risk of CHD (HR 0.70 per IQR; 95% CI: 0.54, 0.91) but not ischaemic stroke (HR 0.87 per IQR; 95% CI: 0.61, 1.25) (Table C in S1 File).
Fig 1. HRs of incident CVD as a function of serum pentadecanoic acid (15:0) in the 60YO study.
Data were fitted using Cox regression models adjusted for baseline age, sex, BMI, alcohol intake, smoking habits, physical activity, education, and prevalent hypertension, hyperlipidaemia, and type 2 diabetes. Dashed lines represent 95% confidence limits. The reference value of serum 15:0 is the 10th percentile (i.e., 0.17% of total fatty acids). The histogram shows the distribution of serum 15:0 in the cohort, and the tick marks under the histogram indicate serum 15:0 levels of individuals who experienced an incident CVD event during follow-up. CVD, cardiovascular disease; HR, hazard ratio.
In the multivariable-adjusted model, there was no significant linear association of serum 15:0 with all-cause mortality (P = 0.38) (Table 2). However, results from the spline analyses suggested a nonlinear association (P for nonlinearity = 0.03) (Table 2), with a nadir of mortality risk around median 15:0 (i.e., 0.22% of total fatty acids) (Fig 2). Evaluation of serum 15:0 quartiles further supported the findings of a nonlinear association, with a 22% lower mortality risk (HR 0.78; 95% CI: 0.62, 0.98) in the third versus first quartile (Table 3). This lower mortality risk translated into a longer survival; the time by which 15% died was 23 months later (95% CI: 1, 45) in the third versus first quartile. Serum 15:0 was not significantly associated with CVD mortality after adjustment for potential confounders (Table C in S1 File).
Fig 2. HRs of all-cause mortality as a function of serum pentadecanoic acid (15:0) in the 60YO study.
Data were fitted using Cox regression models adjusted for baseline age, sex, BMI, alcohol intake, smoking habits, physical activity, education, and prevalent hypertension, hyperlipidaemia, type 2 diabetes, and CVD. Dashed lines represent 95% confidence limits. The reference value of serum 15:0 is the 10th percentile (i.e., 0.17% of total fatty acids). The histogram shows the distribution of serum 15:0 in the cohort and the tick marks under the histogram indicate serum 15:0 levels of individuals who died during follow-up. CVD, cardiovascular disease; HR, hazard ratio.
Stratified and sensitivity analyses.
Associations of serum 15:0 and CVD or mortality outcomes did not differ by sex, BMI, or serum n-3 PUFA levels (Table D in S1 File). Results from sensitivity analyses that adjusted for self-reported dietary habits, excluded early cases (≤2 years after baseline), censored follow-up at 10-years, or excluded individuals with prevalent CVD (in the mortality analyses) did not alter our findings (Table E in S1 File).
Systematic review and meta-analysis
A systematic review of the literature identified 18 studies, including the 60YO, that met the inclusion criteria (Fig 3) [23–41]. The characteristics of the studies and their quality assessment based on NOS are presented in Tables F and G in S1 File. All except one study were considered good-quality studies scoring a total NOS score of between 6 and 9 out of 9, and one study was considered fair quality (Table G in S1 File). The 18 studies together included 42,736 participants (although actual numbers differed for each dairy fat biomarker), and 11,950 total CVD cases were analysed in studies evaluating 15:0; 9,009 in studies evaluating 17:0; and 3,477 in studies evaluating t16:1n-7.
In pooled analyses evaluating high versus low levels of dairy fat biomarkers, 15:0 and 17:0 (Figs 4 and 5), but not t16:1n-7 (Table 4), were inversely associated with total CVD. The RR estimates (95% CI; n studies) of total CVD for the top versus bottom tertiles of 15:0, 17:0, and t16:1n-7 were 0.88 (0.78 to 0.99; n = 17), 0.86 (0.79 to 0.93; n = 12), and 1.01 (0.91 to 1.12; n = 6), respectively. The highest versus lowest tertiles of 17:0, but not 15:0 and t16:1n-7, were significantly associated with lower CHD and stroke risks (Table 4). In the studies allowing evaluation of continuous exposure, each 1 SD increase of 15:0 and 17:0 was inversely associated with total CVD, with RR 0.93 (95% CI 0.86 to 1.00; n = 12) for 15:0 and 0.93 (0.88 to 0.98; n = 9) for 17:0 (Table H in S1 File). Higher versus lower levels of dairy fat biomarkers were not significantly associated with all-cause mortality (Figs 4 and 5 and Table 4).
Fig 4. Risk estimates for CVD incidence and all-cause mortality in the top tertile of pentadecanoic acid (15:0) relative to the bottom tertile.
AT, adipose tissue; CE, cholesterol ester; CHD, coronary heart disease; CI, confidence interval; CVD, cardiovascular disease; HF, heart failure; PP, plasma phospholipids; RBC, red blood cell (erythrocyte); RR, relative risk.
Fig 5. Risk estimates for CVD incidence and all-cause mortality in the top tertile of heptadecanoic acid (17:0) relative to the bottom tertile.
AT, adipose tissue; CE, cholesterol ester; CHD, coronary heart disease; CI, confidence interval; CVD, cardiovascular disease; HF, heart failure; PP, plasma phospholipids; RBC, red blood cell (erythrocyte); RR, relative risk.
There was no statistical evidence that associations of dairy fat biomarkers and CVD risk were modified by age, sex, follow-up duration, or region (Europe versus United States) (Table I in S1 File). However, there was evidence of heterogeneity by age in association of 15:0 and total CVD (P = 0.020). There was no evidence of publication bias on visual inspection of the funnel plots (Fig B in S1 File) and by Begg’s and Egger’s tests.
In a population-based Swedish cohort study (i.e., 60YO), higher circulating levels of 15:0, a biomarker of dairy fat intake, were inversely associated with incident CVD. These findings were supported by our systematic review, which represents the most up-to-date and comprehensive synthesis of the evidence on the relation between dairy fat biomarkers, CVD, and mortality. Overall, higher levels of both odd-chain dairy fat biomarkers 15:0 and 17:0 were associated with 12% to 14% lower risk of CVD, comparing top versus bottom thirds of biomarker levels. Conversely, t16:1n-7 was not related to the risk of CVD. Our meta-analysis results from 3 available studies examining dairy fat biomarkers in relation to all-cause mortality show no clear associations.
Compared to their saturated even-chain fatty acid counterparts, there has been relatively little research into how odd-chain fatty acids might influence cardiovascular risk factors. A recent animal experimental study demonstrated that daily oral supplementation of 15:0 decreased proinflammatory states in obese mice with metabolic syndrome and also lowered total cholesterol . However, this requires replication in human studies. Although the direct metabolic effects of 15:0 and 17:0 are unclear, there is good evidence to suggest that the levels of odd-chain fatty acids may reflect intake of other constituents or nutrients in dairy fat or dairy fat–rich foods that have potential cardiometabolic benefits . For instance, cheese is a major dietary source of vitamin K. Vitamin K may influence CVD risk through vitamin K–dependent proteins and reductions in vascular calcification, although evidence from prospective studies for cardiovascular benefit remains limited and conflicting . Probiotics in dairy foods (such as yoghurt and fermented milk) and their interaction with the human gut microbiota may also confer cardiometabolic benefits . Together, such potential cardioprotective components of dairy foods may partly explain our findings, and our findings are also consistent with prior meta-analyses that show self-reported dairy intake were associated with reduced risk of total CVD by 10% to 12% [44,45]. Given the long-standing and prevalent dietary guidance to consume low-fat dairy products , our results highlight the importance of additional animal-experimental and clinical research into the biologic mechanisms whereby odd-chain dairy fatty acids may influence and prevent CVD.
Dairy and dairy product consumption in Sweden is among the highest worldwide, and their health benefits in the Nordic diet have long been debated [46,47]. While most of the prior prospective studies have focused on cardiovascular outcomes, recent large Swedish studies found higher self-reported intake of nonfermented milk to be positively associated with all-cause mortality [48–50], which was in contrast with meta-analyses of evidence from other countries that found null associations [7,51]. Using an objective measure of dairy fat intake, our findings from the 60YO study suggest a nonlinear association between 15:0 and all-cause mortality. Importantly, even at very high levels of 15:0, there was no significant association with all-cause mortality compared to low levels. These findings appear consistent with those of Iggman and colleagues, who examined adipose tissue 15:0 and 17:0 and also did not detect a significant association with all-cause mortality . Our findings therefore do not support the contention that dairy fat intake, even at the high levels in Nordic countries, might contribute to higher risk of all-cause mortality. However, our systematic search identified relatively few studies that have evaluated dairy fat biomarkers and all-cause mortality, highlighting the need for more studies.
Our systematic review builds on and substantially extends previous meta-analyses [21,52]. Our results confirm the favourable cardiovascular benefits of having higher levels of 17:0 [21,52]. Our synthesis of the literature further generated novel evidence relating higher 15:0 levels with lower CVD risk. In comparison with previous meta-analyses that did not find evidence of an association between 15:0 and CVD outcomes, our review had considerably greater statistical power by including more studies and cases (n = 17 versus n ≤ 12, with approximately 5 times the number of incident CVD cases), consistently used study effect estimates from models adjusting for key potential confounders, and included studies from more diverse countries and geographies. The observed association of 15:0 with total CVD further supports the inverse relationship between dairy fat intake and CVD risk. Interestingly, our findings suggest a null association between t16:1n-7 and CVD risk, consistent with earlier reviews . However, t16:1n-7 is intercorrelated with the 15:0 and 17:0, and each of these dairy fat biomarkers was associated with lower risk of type 2 diabetes, which is a major risk factor of CVD [53,54]. The different association between the odd-chain fatty acids and t16:1n-7 could reflect true differences in their influence on cardiovascular health, or may be due to the relatively fewer number of studies (n = 7) that have investigated t16:1n-7 and/or potential greater measurement errors given the low levels and limited variance of circulating t16:1n-7.
Our study had several strengths. Firstly, the 60YO cohort is a large population-based prospective study with a high participation rate (78%), which reduces the risk of recall and selection biases and enhances the generalisability. Similarly, the inclusion of diverse populations of different age groups, sex, ethnicities, and countries in the systematic review enhances the generalisability of the findings. Secondly, the inclusion of >40,000 participants and >11,000 CVD events in the meta-analysis provides stronger statistical power than previous systematic reviews. Thirdly, dairy fat intake in the cohort study and meta-analysis of prospective studies was measured using objective biomarkers as opposed to a self-reported questionnaire, which avoids self-report or memory bias and errors from inaccurate nutrient composition information, and better captures hidden dairy fat intake in mixed or prepared dishes . Additionally, the biomarkers also allow for investigations into individual dairy fat biomarkers, which may have different biological effects. Lastly, the prospective design of 60YO cohort study and other studies included in the meta-analysis reduced the risk of recall and interviewer bias.
Some limitations of the 60YO cohort study were that serum 15:0 was measured once at baseline, which may have led to misclassification of exposure levels, although such misclassification is likely random and thus may have attenuated our results towards the null. The Swedish hospital discharge and deaths register is traditionally considered accurate, yet some deaths may be misclassified. We also cannot exclude residual confounding from inaccurately measured factors or factors not measured. The vast majority (89%) of the 60YO cohort were born in Sweden (81%) or Finland (8%), and extrapolation of the findings to other ethnic groups should be done with caution. Also, the studies included in the review were from the US, Sweden, Denmark, and the United Kingdom, which limits its generalisability to other regions. Despite several advantages of evaluating fatty acid biomarkers, the results cannot distinguish between different types of dairy foods (e.g., cheese, milk, butter, and yoghurt), which could have differential effects on health [2,55]. For example, butter intake increases total and LDL cholesterol when compared to cheese , and while cheese intake has been linked to lower risk of CVD outcomes [7,56–58], similar associations have not been reported for butter [57–59], which instead was recently linked to increased cardiovascular mortality in a large US cohort . Additionally, the odd-chain saturated fats can be found at lower concentrations in other foods such as meat and fish and can potentially be produced endogenously [12,54]. However, these fatty acids primarily reflect the intake of dairy foods in most Western populations (as shown by the correlation between serum 15:0 and the dairy intake score in the 60YO Swedish cohort in Fig A in S1 File) , given the relatively high intake of dairy compared to fish, and, also, dairy (especially cheese) is the major dietary source of propionate, a primary substrate for the potential endogenous synthesis of odd-chain fatty acids . It is unlikely that the inverse associations are confounded by meat intake, as meat is not associated with lower CVD risk . Furthermore, we observed no change in the association between 15:0 and incident CVD after adjustment for the intake of vegetables, fruit and berries, fish, and meat in the Swedish cohort. In future studies, a detailed dietary assessment should be conducted to investigate and adjust for potential interrelationship between intake of dairy fat, total energy, and macronutrients such as carbohydrates. Our study-level meta-analysis has known limitations such as potential for increased heterogeneity due to differences in study design (e.g., covariate selection) and limited number of studies evaluating certain outcomes (e.g., all-cause mortality). We assumed log-linear associations of biomarkers with outcomes when transforming risk estimates to allow comparison of top versus bottom biomarker tertiles, which may over- or underestimate the estimates. However, meta-analysing risk estimates per biomarker SD in the subset of studies with relevant information available or retrieved from study authors provided similar results. Finally, the limited number of studies per lipid fraction, fatty acid, and outcome combination prevented us from evaluating nonlinear associations using dose–response meta-regression. Many of the limitations to our meta-analysis could be addressed by de novo individual-level pooled analyses of prospective studies utilising harmonised analysis protocols with predefined exposures, outcomes, and models [54,62].
Higher circulating pentadecanoic acid (15:0), a biomarker of dairy fat intake, was associated with lower risk of CVD in this large population-based cohort study in Sweden. Our meta-analysis supports this finding, showing that higher levels of both odd-chain dairy fat biomarkers 15:0 and 17:0 were associated with lower CVD risk but not t16:1n-7. Our findings call for clinical and experimental studies to ascertain the causality of the relationship and the potential role of dairy foods in CVD prevention.
S1 File. Supporting information tables and figures.
Table A. 60YO study population characteristics at baseline by quartile of serum cholesterol ester pentadecanoic acid (15:0). Table B. Hazard ratios of primary (incident CVD and all-cause mortality) and secondary outcomes (incident CHD, stroke, and CVD mortality) with serum 15:0 evaluated per interquintile range, per SD, or per % of totals fatty acids in the 60YO study. Table C. Hazard ratios of incident CHD, stroke, and CVD mortality per interquintile range of serum pentadecanoic acid (15:0) in the 60YO study. Table D. Hazard ratios (95% CI) of incident CVD and all-cause mortality by serum pentadecanoic acid (15:0) (per 1 IQR increase) according to sex, BMI, and serum proportions of long-chain n-3 PUFA in the 60YO study. Table E. Hazard ratios (95% CI) of incident CVD and all-cause mortality by serum pentadecanoic acid (15:0) (per 1 IQR increase) assessed in sensitivity analyses excluding early cases, censoring at 10 years of follow-up or by excluding individuals with prevalent CVD at baseline in the 60YO study. Table F. Characteristics of studies included in the systematic review. Table G. Newcastle–Ottawa Score (NOS) calculation for studies included in the systematic review. Table H. Pooled risk estimates of cardiovascular disease (CVD) subtypes and all-cause mortality per standard deviation (SD) increase in 15:0, 17:0, and t16:1n-7. Table I. Risk estimates of total cardiovascular disease (CVD) comparing top versus bottom tertile of 15:0, 17:0, and t16:1n-7 in subgroups by age, sex, duration of follow-up, or study location. Fig A. Relationship between the dairy intake score and pentadecanoic acid in serum cholesterol esters, evaluated using restricted cubic splines and adjusted for age, sex, BMI, physical activity, alcohol use, and smoking status in the 60YO study. The circles represent the point estimates and the error bars, 95% CIs. The dairy intake score was based on self-reported habits regarding use of butter, cheese, milk, and yoghurt . The histogram shows the distribution of the dairy intake score in the cohort. Fig B. Funnel plot of studies included in the meta-analysis for serum 15:0 (A), 17:0 (B), and t16:1n-7 (C).
The authors thank Siv Tengblad for assessment of FA composition and all cohort participants for their contributions.
Institute for Health Metrics and Evaluation. GBD Compare Seattle: IHME, University of Washington; 2017 [cited 2017 Nov 3]. http://vizhub.healthdata.org/gbd-compare.
Wu JHY, Micha R, Mozaffarian D. Dietary fats and cardiometabolic disease: mechanisms and effects on risk factors and outcomes. Nat Rev Cardiol. 2019;16(10):581–601. pmid:31097791
Hooper L, Martin N, Jimoh OF, Kirk C, Foster E, Abdelhamid AS. Reduction in saturated fat intake for cardiovascular disease. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2020;5(5):Cd011737. pmid:32428300
Mozaffarian D, Wu JHY. Flavonoids, Dairy Foods, and Cardiovascular and Metabolic Health: A Review of Emerging Biologic Pathways. Circ Res. 2018;122(2):369–84. pmid:29348256
Rosqvist F, Smedman A, Lindmark-Månsson H, Paulsson M, Petrus P, Straniero S, et al. Potential role of milk fat globule membrane in modulating plasma lipoproteins, gene expression, and cholesterol metabolism in humans: a randomized study. Am J Clin Nutr. 2015;102(1):20–30. pmid:26016870
Huth PJ, Park KM. Influence of dairy product and milk fat consumption on cardiovascular disease risk: a review of the evidence. Adv Nutr. 2012;3(3):266–85. pmid:22585901
Guo J, Astrup A, Lovegrove JA, Gijsbers L, Givens DI, Soedamah-Muthu SS. Milk and dairy consumption and risk of cardiovascular diseases and all-cause mortality: dose-response meta-analysis of prospective cohort studies. Eur J Epidemiol. 2017;32(4):269–87. pmid:28374228
Lordan R, Tsoupras A, Mitra B, Zabetakis I. Dairy Fats and Cardiovascular Disease: Do We Really Need to Be Concerned? Foods. 2018;7(3):29. pmid:29494487
Guo J, Givens DI, Astrup A, Bakker SJL, Goossens GH, Kratz M, et al. The Impact of Dairy Products in the Development of Type 2 Diabetes: Where Does the Evidence Stand in 2019? Adv Nutr. 2019;10(6):1066–75. pmid:31124561
Astrup A, Magkos F, Bier DM, Brenna JT, de Oliveira Otto MC, Hill JO, et al. Saturated Fats and Health: A Reassessment and Proposal for Food-Based Recommendations. J Am Coll Cardiol. 2020;76(7):844–57. pmid:32562735
Freedman LS, Schatzkin A, Midthune D, Kipnis V. Dealing With Dietary Measurement Error in Nutritional Cohort Studies. J Natl Cancer Inst. 2011;103(14):1086–92. pmid:21653922
Risérus U, Marklund M. Milk fat biomarkers and cardiometabolic disease. Curr Opin Lipidol. 2017;28(1):46–51. pmid:27906713
de Oliveira Otto MC, Lemaitre RN, Sun Q, King IB, Wu JHY, Manichaikul A, et al. Genome-wide association meta-analysis of circulating odd-numbered chain saturated fatty acids: Results from the CHARGE Consortium. PLoS ONE. 2018;13(5):e0196951. pmid:29738550
Wolk A, Furuheim M, Vessby B. Fatty acid composition of adipose tissue and serum lipids are valid biological markers of dairy fat intake in men. J Nutr. 2001;131(3):828–33. pmid:11238766
de Oliveira Otto MC, Lemaitre RN, Song X, King IB, Siscovick DS, Mozaffarian D. Serial measures of circulating biomarkers of dairy fat and total and cause-specific mortality in older adults: the Cardiovascular Health Study. Am J Clin Nutr. 2018;108(3):476–84. pmid:30007304
OECD FAO. Agricultural Outlook 2018-2027- Dairy and Dairy Products: OECD FAO; 2018 [updated 2020 Jul 1; cited 2020 Jul 1]. http://www.agri-outlook.org/commodities/Agricultural-Outlook-2018-Dairy.pdf.
Marklund M, Leander K, Vikstrom M, Laguzzi F, Gigante B, Sjogren P, et al. Polyunsaturated Fat Intake Estimated by Circulating Biomarkers and Risk of Cardiovascular Disease and All-Cause Mortality in a Population-Based Cohort of 60-Year-Old Men and Women. Circulation. 2015;132(7):586–94. pmid:26085453
Boberg M, Croon LB, Gustafsson IB, Vessby B. Platelet fatty acid composition in relation to fatty acid composition in plasma and to serum lipoprotein lipids in healthy subjects with special reference to the linoleic acid pathway. Clin Sci. 1985;68(5):581–7. pmid:3919990
Laguzzi F, Alsharari Z, Risérus U, Vikström M, Sjögren P, Gigante B, et al. Cross-sectional relationships between dietary fat intake and serum cholesterol fatty acids in a Swedish cohort of 60-year-old men and women. J Hum Nutr Diet. 2016;29(3):325–37. pmid:26264885
Orsini N, Wolk A, Bottai M. Evaluating Percentiles of Survival. Epidemiology. 2012;23(5):770–1. pmid:22872120
Liang J, Zhou Q, Kwame Amakye W, Su Y, Zhang Z. Biomarkers of dairy fat intake and risk of cardiovascular disease: A systematic review and meta analysis of prospective studies. Crit Rev Food Sci Nutr. 2018;58(7):1122–30. pmid:28001085
Wells GA SB, O’Connell D, Peterson J, Welch V, Losos M, Tugwell P. The Newcastle-Ottawa Scale (NOS) for assessing the quality if nonrandomized studies in meta-analyses Ontario. 2012 [cited 2020 Jun 15]. http://www.ohri.ca/programs/clinical_epidemiology/oxford.asp.
Warensjö E, Jansson J-H, Berglund L, Boman K, Ahrén B, Weinehall L, et al. Estimated intake of milk fat is negatively associated with cardiovascular risk factors and does not increase the risk of a first acute myocardial infarction. A prospective case-control study. Br J Nutr. 2004;91(4):635–42. pmid:15035691
Warensjö E, Smedman A, Stegmayr B, Hallmans G, Weinehall L, Vessby B, et al. Stroke and plasma markers of milk fat intake—a prospective nested case-control study. Nutr J. 2009;8:21. pmid:19457271
Warensjö E, Jansson J-H, Cederholm T, Boman K, Eliasson M, Hallmans G, et al. Biomarkers of milk fat and the risk of myocardial infarction in men and women: a prospective, matched case-control study. Am J Clin Nutr. 2010;92(1):194–202. pmid:20484449
Biong AS, Veierod MB, Ringstad J, Thelle DS, Pedersen JI. Intake of milk fat, reflected in adipose tissue fatty acids and risk of myocardial infarction: a case-control study. Eur J Clin Nutr. 2006;60(2):236–44. pmid:16267503
Sun Q, Ma J, Campos H, Hu FB. Plasma and erythrocyte biomarkers of dairy fat intake and risk of ischemic heart disease. Am J Clin Nutr. 2007;86(4):929–37. pmid:17921367
Yamagishi K, Nettleton JA, Folsom AR, Investigators AS. Plasma fatty acid composition and incident heart failure in middle-aged adults: the Atherosclerosis Risk in Communities (ARIC) Study. Am Heart J. 2008;156(5):965–74. pmid:19061714
Yamagishi K, Folsom AR, Steffen LM. Plasma fatty acid composition and incident ischemic stroke in middle-aged adults: the Atherosclerosis Risk in Communities (ARIC) Study. Cerebrovasc Dis. 2013;36(1):38–46. pmid:23920478
Khaw K-T, Friesen MD, Riboli E, Luben R, Wareham N. Plasma phospholipid fatty acid concentration and incident coronary heart disease in men and women: the EPIC-Norfolk prospective study. PLoS Med. 2012;9(7):e1001255–e. pmid:22802735
Malik VS, Wu H, Hu FB, Sun Q. Plasma and erythrocyte biomarkers of dairy fat intake and risk of coronary heart disease in men. Circulation. 2012;125(10).
Otto MCD, Nettleton JA, Lemaitre RN, Steffen LM, Kromhout D, Rich SS, et al. Biomarkers of Dairy Fatty Acids and Risk of Cardiovascular Disease in the Multi-Ethnic Study of Atherosclerosis. J Am Heart Assoc. 2013;2(4). pmid:23868191
Matsumoto C, Hanson NQ, Tsai MY, Glynn RJ, Gaziano JM, Djoussé L. Plasma phospholipid saturated fatty acids and heart failure risk in the Physicians’ Health Study. Clin Nutr. 2013;32(5):819–23. pmid:23473794
Tokede OA, Petrone AB, Hanson NQ, Tsai MY, Weir NA, Glynn RJ, et al. Plasma phospholipid trans fatty acids and risk of heart failure. Am J Clin Nutr. 2013;97(4):698–705. pmid:23446892
Yaemsiri S, Sen S, Tinker LF, Robinson WR, Evans RW, Rosamond W, et al. Serum fatty acids and incidence of ischemic stroke among postmenopausal women. Stroke. 2013;44(10):2710–7. pmid:23899914
Matthan NR, Ooi EM, Van Horn L, Neuhouser ML, Woodman R, Lichtenstein AH. Plasma phospholipid fatty acid biomarkers of dietary fat quality and endogenous metabolism predict coronary heart disease risk: a nested case-control study within the Women’s Health Initiative observational study. J Am Heart Assoc. 2014;3(4):e000764. pmid:25122663
Yakoob MY, Shi P, Hu FB, Campos H, Rexrode KM, Orav EJ, et al. Circulating biomarkers of dairy fat and risk of incident stroke in U.S. men and women in 2 large prospective cohorts. Am J Clin Nutr. 2014;100(6):1437–47. pmid:25411278
Kleber ME, Delgado GE, Lorkowski S, März W, von Schacky C. Trans-fatty acids and mortality in patients referred for coronary angiography: the Ludwigshafen Risk and Cardiovascular Health Study. Eur Heart J. 2016;37(13):1072–8. pmid:26396230
Iggman D, Ärnlöv J, Cederholm T, Risérus U. Association of Adipose Tissue Fatty Acids With Cardiovascular and All-Cause Mortality in Elderly Men. JAMA Cardiol. 2016;1(7):745–53. pmid:27541681
Laursen ASD, Dahm CC, Johnsen SP, Schmidt EB, Overvad K, Jakobsen MU. Adipose tissue fatty acids present in dairy fat and risk of stroke: the Danish Diet, Cancer and Health cohort. Eur J Nutr. 2019;58(2):529–39. pmid:29330661
Borgeraas H, Hertel JK, Seifert R, Berge RK, Bohov P, Ueland PM, et al. Serum trans fatty acids, asymmetric dimethylarginine and risk of acute myocardial infarction and mortality in patients with suspected coronary heart disease: a prospective cohort study. Lipids Health Dis. 2016;15:38-. pmid:26920731
Venn-Watson S, Lumpkin R, Dennis EA. Efficacy of dietary odd-chain saturated fatty acid pentadecanoic acid parallels broad associated health benefits in humans: could it be essential? Sci Rep. 2020;10(1):8161. pmid:32424181
Shioi A, Morioka T, Shoji T, Emoto M. The Inhibitory Roles of Vitamin K in Progression of Vascular Calcification. Nutrients. 2020;12(2). pmid:32102248
Gholami F, Khoramdad M, Esmailnasab N, Moradi G, Nouri B, Safiri S, et al. The effect of dairy consumption on the prevention of cardiovascular diseases: A meta-analysis of prospective studies. J Cardiovasc Thorac Res. 2017;9(1):1–11. pmid:28451082
Qin LQ, Xu JY, Han SF, Zhang ZL, Zhao YY, Szeto IM. Dairy consumption and risk of cardiovascular disease: an updated meta-analysis of prospective cohort studies. Asia Pac J Clin Nutr. 2015;24(1):90–100. pmid:25740747
Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations. Food Balance Sheets. 2017 [cited 2020 Jul 1]. http://www.fao.org/faostat/en/#data/FBS/visualize.
Astrup AGD. Confusing message about dairy from Sweden (Rapid response to Milk intake and risk of mortality and fractures in women and men: cohort studies). BMJ. 2014;349:g6015. pmid:25352269
Tognon G, Rothenberg E, Petrolo M, Sundh V, Lissner L. Dairy product intake and mortality in a cohort of 70-year-old Swedes: a contribution to the Nordic diet discussion. Eur J Nutr. 2018;57(8):2869–76. pmid:29080977
Michaëlsson K, Wolk A, Langenskiöld S, Basu S, Warensjö Lemming E, Melhus H, et al. Milk intake and risk of mortality and fractures in women and men: cohort studies. BMJ. 2014;349:g6015. pmid:25352269
Tognon G, Nilsson LM, Shungin D, Lissner L, Jansson J-H, Renström F, et al. Nonfermented milk and other dairy products: associations with all-cause mortality. Am J Clin Nutr. 2017;105(6):1502–11. pmid:28490510
Larsson SC, Crippa A, Orsini N, Wolk A, Michaëlsson K. Milk Consumption and Mortality from All Causes, Cardiovascular Disease, and Cancer: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. Nutrients. 2015;7(9):7749–63. pmid:26378576
Chowdhury R, Warnakula S, Kunutsor S, Crowe F, Ward HA, Johnson L, et al. Association of dietary, circulating, and supplement fatty acids with coronary risk: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Ann Intern Med. 2014;160(6):398–406. pmid:24723079
Yakoob MY, Shi P, Willett WC, Rexrode KM, Campos H, Orav EJ, et al. Circulating Biomarkers of Dairy Fat and Risk of Incident Diabetes Mellitus Among Men and Women in the United States in Two Large Prospective Cohorts. Circulation. 2016;133(17):1645–54. pmid:27006479
Imamura F, Fretts A, Marklund M, Ardisson Korat AV, Yang W-S, Lankinen M, et al. Fatty acid biomarkers of dairy fat consumption and incidence of type 2 diabetes: A pooled analysis of prospective cohort studies. PLoS Med. 2018;15(10):e1002670. pmid:30303968
Astrup A, Geiker NRW, Magkos F. Effects of Full-Fat and Fermented Dairy Products on Cardiometabolic Disease: Food Is More Than the Sum of Its Parts. Adv Nutr. 2019;10(5):924S–30S. pmid:31518411 J Advances in Nutrition.
Hjerpsted J, Leedo E, Tholstrup T. Cheese intake in large amounts lowers LDL-cholesterol concentrations compared with butter intake of equal fat content. Am J Clin Nutr. 2011;94(6):1479–84. pmid:22030228
Jakobsen MU, Trolle E, Outzen M, Mejborn H, Grønberg MG, Lyndgaard CB, et al. Intake of dairy products and associations with major atherosclerotic cardiovascular diseases: a systematic review and meta-analysis of cohort studies. Sci Rep. 2021;11(1):1303. pmid:33446728
Fontecha J, Calvo MV, Juarez M, Gil A, Martínez-Vizcaino V. Milk and Dairy Product Consumption and Cardiovascular Diseases: An Overview of Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses. Adv Nutr. 2019;10(suppl_2):S164–s89. pmid:31089735
Pimpin L, Wu JH, Haskelberg H, Del Gobbo L, Mozaffarian D. Is Butter Back? A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Butter Consumption and Risk of Cardiovascular Disease, Diabetes, and Total Mortality. PLoS ONE. 2016;11(6):e0158118. pmid:27355649
Zhang Y, Zhuang P, Wu F, He W, Mao L, Jia W, et al. Cooking oil/fat consumption and deaths from cardiometabolic diseases and other causes: prospective analysis of 521,120 individuals. BMC Med. 2021;19(1):92. pmid:33853582
Micha R, Wallace SK, Mozaffarian D. Red and processed meat consumption and risk of incident coronary heart disease, stroke, and diabetes mellitus: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Circulation. 2010;121(21):2271–83. pmid:20479151
Marklund M, Wu JHY, Imamura F, Del Gobbo LC, Fretts A, de Goede J, et al. Biomarkers of Dietary Omega-6 Fatty Acids and Incident Cardiovascular Disease and Mortality. Circulation. 2019;139(21):2422–36. pmid:30971107